The Jackie Sherman Group, Inc.

Business Consulting

Partnering With Leaders
For Effective Change

  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • About Jackie Sherman
    • How We Work
    • Our Clients
  • What We Do
    • Organization Effectiveness Consulting
    • Nonprofit Consulting
    • Meeting Design & Facilitation
    • Executive Coaching
  • Client Successes
  • Blog
  • Contact

6 Clear Steps to Greater Influence: Join Before Differentiating

By Jackie Sherman

 

Join Before Differentiating

Many years ago I participated in a training for facilitating groups, and my group was working on solving a problem that required us to influence each other. I thought I had a good idea for what we should do, and offered it with direct language. The group, however, continued talking about their own idea. They ignored me. I tried again, but their idea had gained even more steam, and they still ignored me.

After my third attempt, the instructor intervened with a simple but powerful strategy: Join Before Differentiating. Jackie, each time you try to lead the group in a different direction, you focus on what you want, but you don’t connect at all with what they are saying,” he said. “You are differentiating—stating a different perspective. Try connecting with—joining—their idea first, before making your suggestion.”

By practicing this, my ability to influence has improved dramatically. This was a profound lesson for me.  Over the years, I have shared this with many people who have expressed frustration about their inability to influence effectively.  This blog will explain why your ideas fail to gain traction, and show you how to influence more effectively by joining before differentiating.

You may recognize this move from improv theatre, where the golden rule is known as, “Yes, and…” Good improv actors know that you never reject where your acting partners are going. “No” never works – it just stops the action. With an explicit or implicit acknowledgment, you accept the direction of the others on stage before taking the plot in a new direction.

Joining before differentiating is an important approach for influencing individuals as well as groups. Many of us relate to this situation: You listen as someone—a friend, colleague, client, or even your boss—describes a problem and their idea for solving it. The person wants your input.  You have an idea that you are sure will work better.  “I think you would be more effective if you tried thus and such,” you answer.

The person pauses and may even look taken aback—then resumes talking about their idea. You push back several times, but get no traction.

Working with Resistance

In these situations, the energy of the group or person is moving in a certain direction, and you attempt to push against that energy, or pull it toward you, by offering a different solution.

When the group or individual pushes back or pulls away, you are experiencing resistance. It is not direct, because no one says, “I disagree.” They just don’t consider your idea.

Resistance is just energy.  You can’t overcome it. You need to accept it and work with it.  I know this is counter to how most people talk about resistance. There is so much more to say about working with resistance, but I’ll have to save that for a future blog post.

A helpful analogy comes from aikido, the traditional Japanese martial art. To turn or move your opponent’s energy, if you push, it only leads to them pushing back, escalating into a struggle for power. A more effective solution is to “accept” or join the other person’s energy first, which allows you to direct it more successfully. Another way to remember this is “connect to direct” – a broader lesson for leaders.

Here’s another example. Brian, a marketing executive I coached, was having no luck getting his boss to consider his suggestions. Their typical conversation went like a ping pong match. Brian would bring him a marketing idea to consider, his boss would have another idea, Brian would respond with his idea again. After a few rounds Brian would give up, and frankly I think most of us would too.

We talked through the possibility of Brian joining his boss’s idea before he offered his own. We practiced, with Brian playing the role of his boss and me demonstrating first how Brian had been communicating, then how he could join before differentiating. This role reversal, and rehearsal, helped him experience the receiving end of his communication style. The light bulb went off.

At the next opportunity, Brian tried this approach. He happily reported that his boss “suddenly became receptive.” The change was that radical.  By joining first, before differentiating, Brian connected with his boss and his idea, and completely changed their dynamic. Brian’s frustration went down as his ideas gained traction and his influence increased.

Join Before Differentiating: A 6-Step Process to Greater Influence

By practicing the following six steps, you will get your ideas considered and redirect the energy of a person or group.

Step 1: Connect with the group/person’s idea.

There are multiple ways to do this.

Ask a clarifying question, one to better understand the idea. (Example: “Tell me more about how that would work.”)

Find something about the group/person’s idea that you genuinely like, or think might work. (Example: “I can see how this and that about your idea could work.”)

Let this sink in to you and them. Don’t rush to the next step.

Step 2: Build the bridge to your idea.

Example: “Would you be open to another idea?”

Example: “I’d like to offer another option; are you open to that?”

Step 3: Wait for their reply.

You must respect their wishes. Frankly, if they’re not open to a different idea, then you will waste your energy by offering it.

If they are interested …

Step 4: Offer your idea.

As you do, it’s important to resist the temptation to “diss” their idea or you will undo what you have just built.

Step 5: Ask if they have any questions about it, or if it makes sense.

At this point they may start talking about your idea, and see how it might improve their own.

Step 6: Ask a final question: “What do you think?”

Their answer lets you know what they think of your idea – did they consider it? Decide to do something else? Accept it?

Important Reminders

  • Acknowledging another’s idea or its value, is not agreeing with the idea.
  • You must communicate with authenticity. People can pick up fakeness a mile away. If you are not genuine, you will come across as trying to manipulate.
  • If you are part of the group you are trying to influence, you of course will have more investment in your idea’s acceptance. You will want to hold on to it tightly. As the group or person takes more ownership of your idea, and becomes more likely to implement, you want to hold it lightly.
  • When someone else is entirely responsible for the acceptance or implementation of your idea, you must offer the idea without attachment.
  • For those of us who often believe our ideas are superior, validating another’s idea may not be easy. Study and emulate others who do this quite naturally.

Keep the Conversation Going

As you practice the six steps to master joining before differentiating, let me know how it goes! I’m eager to hear if the results are as effective for your leadership as they have been for others. What methods of communication help you address resistance and be influential?

Find this interesting? Please share:

Comments

  1. Rob Johnson says

    February 1, 2017 at 3:36 pm

    Another GOOD one, Jackie! Will share this, but start by paying attention to how well I’m applying those steps myself.

    Reply
    • Jackie Sherman says

      February 3, 2017 at 6:48 pm

      Great place to start Rob.

      Reply
  2. Ann Hendricks says

    February 2, 2017 at 8:31 am

    This is applicable to so many situations. Will share with several others. Thanks for such a clear piece.

    Reply
    • Jackie Sherman says

      February 3, 2017 at 6:48 pm

      Thanks. Please share liberally.

      Reply
  3. Ann says

    February 2, 2017 at 5:42 pm

    A great article Jackie! We all need to focus on joining before differentiating in these days of polarization.

    Reply
    • Jackie Sherman says

      February 3, 2017 at 6:49 pm

      Thank you.

      Reply
  4. Ginny says

    February 3, 2017 at 11:03 am

    Excellent and succinct, Jackie.

    Reply
    • Jackie Sherman says

      February 3, 2017 at 6:49 pm

      Thank you Ginny.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Updates

* indicates required

Jackie Sherman

The Jackie Sherman Group is just one part of the equation. We only succeed in partnership with a committed client. Are you ready for success?
Read More…

Read About:

  • ►Client Success Stories
    • ►Organization Effectiveness Consulting
    • ►Nonprofit Consulting
    • ►Meeting Design & Facilitation
    • ►Executive Coaching
  • ▼Blog
    • 5 Key Steps to Effective Meetings - Making the Most of Your Investment in Meeting
    • 6 Clear Steps to Greater Influence: Join Before Differentiating
    • 7 Ways to Know If It's Time for A New Strategic Plan
    • Creating the Energy for Change
    • For Greater Alignment, Go Slow to Go Fast
    • How to Lead Effectively Through Resistance
    • If Your Senior Leadership Team Needs To Be More Effective, Get this Timeless Book

What Our Clients Say:

Donna Willis

There's something different about the way you're able to relate. It feels more genuine than simply that you're doing a job; while always being exceedingly professional.

Donna Willis
Former Board Chair / Actor's Express

Bruce Carmichael

For 2 1/2 years Jackie provided consulting support to our diversity leadership group and facilitated numerous large and small group interventions thorough our business unit. She is very talented and brings to the table an extensive experience base coupled with a level of insight not found in many consultants. I recommend her highly.

Bruce Carmichael
Human Resources Manager (retired) / BP Corporation

Micah Porter

Coaching with Jackie has helped me in taking a softer, more personal approach to working with clients. She has an ability to listen very closely, not just to the verbal, but also the nonverbal. She knows when to dig deeper and notices what I didn’t see about myself before. She has also helped me become more systematic and consistent as a small business owner.

Micah Porter, CFA, CFP
President and CEO / Minerva Planning Group

Brian Williams

Jackie got me to slow down, which gave me space to think differently. She especially helped me, in my leadership role, work through getting others to collaborate and think through challenges on their own. Jackie creates a good connection, where I can speak freely and feel listened to – it has been valuable for my personal development.

Brian Williams
VP Development / Select Medical Corporation

Marianne Garber – AA

Jackie led us through a strategic planning process that included input from our multi-generational congregation and leadership team, resulting in a dynamic plan that we put immediately into action. The outcome is that we’ve experienced a new level of growth and vibrancy for our congregation. Jackie is highly skilled at working with groups – she was just the right person for this endeavor.

Marianne Garber, PhD
Ahavath Achim Synagogue

Emily Pelton

Jackie facilitated a strategic planning process for our organization that received very positive feedback from our board and donors. I was impressed by her ability to work through the high-level conceptual challenges. And as a leader, I truly appreciated her willingness to ask the hard questions and challenge me to think things through, which always improves the end product.

Emily Pelton
Executive Director / Refugee Family Services

Lara Dorfman

The strategic planning process Jackie facilitated resulted in a plan and structure that has enabled us to better organize our work, broaden our service area, improve fundraising, and engage volunteers – the plan helps us fulfill our mission. Jackie did a great job of managing all of our opinions and passion in an honest, but delicate way.

Lara Dorfman
Executive Director (former) / Jewish Educational Loan Fund

Jeff Alpern

I’m so pleased that, several years after working with Jackie to complete our strategic plan, we are running the organization using the plan as an actionable template. The plan has become embedded into our culture. Jackie’s approach is smart, practical and very thorough. We trusted her process and got the result we wanted.

Jeff Alperin
Board Member / Jewish Educational Loan Fund

Jennifer Bauer-Lyons

Jackie’s coaching has helped me to lead better in what can be an emotionally charged theatre environment. She helps me get to the core issues, deal with the bigger picture, and formulate an action plan. She is very responsive and resourceful and draws from her deep experience in both the for-profit and non-profit worlds, which gives us new perspectives and insights.

Jennifer Bauer-Lyons
Managing Producer (former) / Horizon Theatre Company

Mary Ellen Davis

Jackie has been a coach and strategic thinking partner for me since 2004. She is a great listener and her broad base of knowledge provides an outside perspective to think through problems in ways I can’t do on my own. Jackie helps me come up with processes, is good at showing me my strengths, and she’s helped me add very useful tools to my toolbox.

MED
Executive Director / National Membership Association

Marian McClellan

You can either win or lose during a transition, so it’s important to pay attention to this critical time. The first transition Jackie coached me through was so successful that I have retained her for every work transition for the last 10 years. She helps me get a clear view of the situation and approach it strategically. Her keen observation skills set her apart from everyone else I’ve worked with.

Marian McClellan

Ralph Clements

Jackie helped me 'see' the right questions to ask.

Ralph Clements
VP of Manufacturing and Technology (former) / BP Fabrics and Fibers and Imperial Sugar

Brad Mortimer

We made dramatic progress in 300 days.  I don’t usually praise consultants in public,   but we couldn’t have done this without Jackie Sherman.

Brad Mortimer
Retired President / Propex Fabrics Company

Patrick Prevost

Please accept my sincere thanks for your excellent organisation. It really made it a successful event!  Your dedication and your support to the design team were essential factors in this success.  You managed to keep us on track with the schedule without constraining the group's creativity.  I was positively surprised with the way we were able to engage such a large group and raise all the critical issues.  And it was quite remarkable to see us achieve consensus around a very good list of action items.  A lot of this, was due to your engagement and experience!

Patrick Prevost
Strategy and Development Manager (former) / BP Chemicals

Emily Deakins

Working with Jackie was truly a developmental experience and a real pleasure.  She was able to “get to know me” very quickly, using probing questions and strong listening skills, and then effectively used that knowledge to ask challenging questions throughout the coaching experience, forcing me to look at things differently and explore different options.  She brings a holistic approach to coaching, helping the client discover the connections between different aspects of work and life, and the interdependencies of mental, physical and emotional states.  It is this unique approach, and the resulting new awareness found, which has made a long lasting difference for me.

VP Global Diversity / Fortune 50 Company

Dianne Smith

I have worked with a variety of consultants over the years and have only highest praise for Jackie’s consulting abilities. She worked with a variety of individual and groups during our project. In each of these relationships she met and exceeded our expectations. We would jump at the chance to re-engage Jackie in the future on any organizational change or organizational development project.

Dianne Smith
Director of Human Resources / Emory University General Libraries

Frances Maloy

You helped us with many important changes. Our organization is a different place now. We have greatly improved our communication and decision-making. The 3 years that we worked together were very rewarding for me and rich with learning. I had very challenging times and I could not have made it through without your support. I believe the library has a better result from our reorganization because of your involvement with us.

Frances Maloy
Division Leader and Redesign Project Manager / Emory University General Libraries

K’Lynne Johnson

Since 1999, I've had the pleasure of working with Jackie in multiple roles and scenarios.  Her expertise in effective organization design, change and leadership is unique both because of her truly global, diverse experience base; and because of her deep theoretical knowledge paired with ongoing practical application.

K'Lynne Johnson
CEO (former) / Elevance Renewable Sciences

Morinee Terry

Jackie meets you where you are, works with you to clarify where you want to go, and helps you get there! She has a gift for creating an environment where you can sense her expertise at work without feeling like the latest 'coaching tool' is being pulled out and used on you. Her commitment to excellence, growth, and success has been instrumental in helping me achieve several professional and personal goals.  

Morinee Terry
Human Resources Manager

Pages

  • Home Page
  • About Jackie Sherman
  • Blog
  • Contact

Read About

  • ▼Blog
    • 5 Key Steps to Effective Meetings - Making the Most of Your Investment in Meeting
    • 6 Clear Steps to Greater Influence: Join Before Differentiating
    • 7 Ways to Know If It's Time for A New Strategic Plan
    • Creating the Energy for Change
    • For Greater Alignment, Go Slow to Go Fast
    • How to Lead Effectively Through Resistance
    • If Your Senior Leadership Team Needs To Be More Effective, Get this Timeless Book
  • ►Client Success Stories
    • ►Executive Coaching
    • ►Meeting Design & Facilitation
    • ►Nonprofit Consulting
    • ►Organization Effectiveness Consulting

Follow Us

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Contact Us

The Jackie Sherman Group
Jackie@jackieshermangroup.com
1608 Bubbling Creek Rd. NE
Atlanta, Georgia 30319
Call: 678-358-4267
Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 The Jackie Sherman Group · New Tricks Web Design